Market News

 May 04, 2012
Heartland Institute Compares Climate Science Believers & Reporters To Mass 'Murderers & Madmen'

 The Heartland Institute has launched one of the most offensive billboard campaigns in U.S. history. The Chicago-based anti-science think tank is comparing all those who accept climate science --- and the journalists who report on it accurately --- to Charles Manson, the Unabomber, and Osama Bin Laden.

Heartland Institute buys Chicago billboards along Eisenhower Expressway

This far-beyond-the-pale ad campaign to promote their Chicago conference later this month is a moment of truth for both the think tank and the broader community of disinformers and their enablers.

Will confirmed speakers like Rep. James Sensenbrenner (R-WI), Czech President Vasclav Klaus, Joe Bastardi, Pat Michaels, Fred Singer, or former NASA astronauts show up at the conference, thereby endorsing this beyond-extremist message? Will leading deniers denounce these offensive ads --- or will they implicitly endorse this kind of hate speech? Will media outlets like PBS keep quoting Heartland 'experts' as if they were a legitimate source of information?

GM ended their financial support of Heartland earlier this month, as has AT&T, but why are State Farm and Microsoft still supporting it? Many other public corporations have donated money or provided resources to Heartland, including Eli Lilly & Co., GlaxoSmithKline, Nucor, Pfizer, and Time Warner Cable. Will they cut ties or implicitly endorse these extreme ads?

The UK Guardian, which broke the story this morning, calls this "possibly one of the most ill-judged poster campaigns in the history of ill-judged poster campaigns.

But let's be clear. This is not some "oops" moment by an individual overzealous Heartland employee with catastrophically poor judgment. Quite the reverse.

This is a collective act by the Institute expressing its core worldview. These billboards aren't cheap. A sustained campaign would be a major expense for any group, signed off at the highest levels. Heartland displays the above image on its main website, proudly announcing its campaign and linking to its robust defense of "Our Billboards" on its conference website.

Heartland's detailed rationalization for its hate speech confirms the very worst views of this right-wing group. I'll quote it at length since it is so self-discrediting:

Billboards in Chicago paid for by The Heartland Institute point out that some of the world's most notorious criminals say they "still believe in global warming" -- and ask viewers if they do, too...

The billboard series features Ted Kaczynski, the infamous Unabomber; Charles Manson, a mass murderer; and Fidel Castro, a tyrant. Other global warming alarmists who may appear on future billboards include Osama bin Laden and James J. Lee (who took hostages inside the headquarters of the Discovery Channel in 2010).

These rogues and villains were chosen because they made public statements about how man-made global warming is a crisis and how mankind must take immediate and drastic actions to stop it.

Why did Heartland choose to feature these people on its billboards?

Because what these murderers and madmen have said differs very little from what spokespersons for the United Nations, journalists for the "mainstream" media, and liberal politicians say about global warming....

The point is that believing in global warming is not "mainstream," smart, or sophisticated. In fact, it is just the opposite of those things. Still believing in man-made global warming -- after all the scientific discoveries and revelations that point against this theory -- is more than a little nutty. In fact, some really crazy people use it to justify immoral and frightening behavior.

You just can't make this stuff up --- unless you are a group of professional disinformers.

Oh, but Heartland wants you to know that not every single climate scientist --- nor every member of the over 120 governments who sign off on the IPCC assessment reports nor every reporter who writes accurately --- is like a psychopath:

Of course, not all global warming alarmists are murderers or tyrants.

Seriously. And yet they write:

The people who still believe in man-made global warming are mostly on the radical fringe of society. This is why the most prominent advocates of global warming aren't scientists. They are murderers, tyrants, and madmen.

Has there ever been a more insidious attack in this country on scientists and reporters --- and millions of Americans who are alarmed and concerned about global warming based solely on what the science actually says?

One can't even get into the internal logic of this nonsense. Outside of the climate blogosphere (and viewers of Fox News), it's doubtful that more than a few percent of the public has any notion that these crazed individuals happen to have expressed views on global warming. They aren't "the most prominent advocates."

One word on the late Osama Bin Laden. Terrorists try very hard to spread their disinformation. A key goal is to get others to spread it for them, especially ones who are holed up in a cave somewhere --- or who are now dead. Thus terrorists craft their disinformation into a sensational message that they hope gullible members of the global media will repeat. If Heartland runs a billboard with Bin Laden's image pushing his disinformation, it will be even a lower low for them (see here).

Heartland's entire justification for taking anti-science, anti-scientist hate speech to a new level --- and plastering it over the Dwight D Eisenhower Expressway in Illinois --- are the "Climategate" stolen emails and the incident in which Peter Gleick admitted using deception to obtain Heartland documents (which Gleick subsequently acknowledged was "a serious lapse of my own and professional judgment and ethics").

Yet, several climate scientists who "had their emails stolen [in 2009], posted online and grossly misrepresented," slammed Heartland for "spreading misinformation" and "personally attacking climate scientists to further its goals." The scientists specifically noted:

In 2009, the Heartland Institute was among the groups that spread false allegations about what these stolen emails said. Despite multiple independent investigations, which demonstrated that allegations against scientists were false, the Heartland Institute continued to attack scientists based on the stolen emails. When more stolen emails were posted online in 2011, the Heartland Institute again pointed to their release and spread false claims about scientists.

You can read Heartland's reply to similar charges here. Climategate isn't a justification for Heartland to smear those who accept climate science. Quite the reverse. It is a reason for an apology, albeit one that pales in comparison to the mea culpas needed for this billboard campaign.

Does the Heartland Board stand behind these ads? The full list is here. Many of them live in Chicago. Does this really express their worldview?

Everyone needs to go on record on this. These ads are so extremist that failing to denounce them is an implicit endorsement of the worst kind of hate speech.